Revolutions are rarely about new ideas. They are often about looking backward and reviving old values and traditions.
The Deiss family from the region of Alsace in France has been leading a return to the days before strict appellation rules of monoculture farming and monovarietal winemaking. Co-plantation and field blending are the status quo at Domaine Marcel Deiss and the family’s more experimental domaine, Vignoble du Reveur.
In this week’s episode, the dynamic farmer and winemaker Mathieu Deiss explains how his domaine’s radical rejection of convention ensures measurable success amid a dramatically changing climate. He makes the case for field blending among much else, as his preferred best method for expressing terroir.
Next week’s guest is Pax Mahle from California.
Be sure to subscribe to Skurnik Unfiltered wherever you find your podcasts so you can stay up to date on all the exciting content to come.
Introduction
Mathieu Deiss 0:03
If you listen to society, globally you hear more and more words like “biodiversity” and “resilience.” This is very trendy. They put in trees, they put in flowers, but at the end, it’s a monoculture of wine. The stronger tool we have is to actually look at the answer that people had before. Complantation is breaking this idea of monoculture with only one variety, one point.
[music]
Harmon Skurnik 0:32
Hey, this is Harmon Skurnik, and welcome to another episode of Skurnik Unfiltered. Today I have with me our Chief French Officer, Mr. David Hinkle. Proud to have you with me, David. How are you?
David Hinkle 0:46
I’m great, Harmon. Happy to be here. A fun subject today.
Harmon Skurnik 0:50
It is. When you think of Alsace as a region in the wine world, you have Riesling, you have Gewürztraminer, you have Pinot Blanc, etc., and each producer is different, and each producer has a certain expression, but they all have kind of the same MO, if you will. Domaine Marcel Deiss is different, isn’t it?
David Hinkle 1:08
We are turning that upside down today. Jean-Michel Deiss, Mathieu’s father, is still fully involved. His wife is also an enologist, works closely with the family, Mathieu’s wife is involved. This is a family affair, and they are all about terroir. They really have changed the way virtually everybody thinks about Alsace today. Everybody is thinking more about blending.
Harmon Skurnik 1:36
And not just blending, but co-planting, right?
David Hinkle 1:38
Co-planting, exactly. Thank you, Harmon. Because that is what Mathieu’s going to talk a lot about. We’re talking today after the 2026 harvest, which was one of the earliest ever—historic. And a lot of what they’re doing harkens back to the way that wine used to be made, and in many ways, is one of the solutions to global warming and climate change, this idea that planting the grapes together, harvesting them all, which the Deisses do, at the same time. There’s a natural balance. It’s the way things used to be. There was a harmony in the farming.
Harmon Skurnik 2:18
When did Domaine Marcel Deiss have this transformation to go back and recreate the way it used to be done?
David Hinkle 2:26
It was Jean-Michel who was the one who did it. He took over back in 1981, and then he slowly started to move to organic farming. One of the first things that he realized in his Grand Cru vineyards was something he discovered when he was working the vines, that a lot of the grapes were all planted together. And for him, a light bulb came on: this is how it used to be. It used to be the Pinot Blanc, Riesling, Gewürztraminer planted together, and it was just something that was done as a hedge against Mother Nature hurting one varietal. But what they soon realized was that the vines communicated underground in a way that it was almost like they talked to each other. They helped each other. The strengths of one grape, the defenses of one grape helped another. And people have found that there are these natural defenses that—not just vineyards, but also farms that—you basically rotate crops, you plant things together near each other, and all of that helps to moderate the whole. And it helped them in 2026, this harvest—a scorching summer, no rain for two months. And this is the type of thing that the Deisses and others feel is a solution moving forward to give them hope, and frankly, not have a 2003 situation, which you and I remember was a harvest where the farming was not at this level. The preparations, they weren’t planting trees like the Deisses, and many of our growers do today, to give some shade. All these things are part of what Mathieu and our growers are doing.
Harmon Skurnik 4:10
Does biodynamics enter into that equation as well? They’ve been a biodynamic estate for over 25 years, right?
David Hinkle 4:18
I think there’s no question that biodynamic farming helps with the health of the vineyards. They make them stronger, more resilient. They hold up to the heat, they retain the water better, the canopy management, the agroforestry, the different varietals all being planted and harvested and vinified together, all of that, the various strengths, one varietal helps another. It’s a remarkable thing, but it’s something that old-timers used to do naturally without thinking twice about, and that’s what Mathieu is going to talk a lot about. He’s just hearkening back to things his father had heard, his grandfather had heard.
Harmon Skurnik 5:01
Biodynamics and even organic farming—a lot of people perceive that as something new. Like, we’re going to be doing organic farming as if chemical farming and conventional farming was traditional. But the fact of the matter is, this, what you’re describing, and also organic and biodynamic farming, is the tradition. That’s what it used to be before World War II. It was only since the war did they come out with Monsanto chemicals to make the job easier because you didn’t have the labor and all that kind of stuff. It’s really a return and a hearken back to tradition.
David Hinkle 5:33
Totally. And the interesting thing is folks like Mathieu and others have gone back to notebooks that others had had. They have looked at what people did 50 years ago, 75 years ago, read the notebooks. It’s kind of remarkable. It really is a turn back to doing something simpler that actually works better at the end of the day and is a lot better for us and is producing some really great and balanced wines today.
Harmon Skurnik 6:01
In addition to Domaine Marcel Deiss, there’s another project. It’s called Vignoble du Rêveur, the Dreamer’s Vineyard. It’s a completely separate property, right?
David Hinkle 6:11
It’s a separate property. It actually was Mathieu’s uncle’s. It was about 2012, 2013 when Mathieu was obviously working with his father, Jean-Michel, and they agreed to take this over. It was an incubator for a lot of the ideas because the Marcel Deiss property took some time to transition. And Rêveur allowed Mathieu and his wife and his father, Jean-Michel, a lot of experiments on maceration to help give the wine strength without needing sulfur. They did a lot of this experimentation in the vineyards and all of these techniques that they did on the vines and in the cellar to help express the terroir in a better way. They were able to do some of those at the early stages. They did them first at Rêveur. And those wines are maybe a little bit more pushing the envelope without, as Mathieu likes to say, jumping off the cliff here, but we want to do things as naturally as possible and respectful to the terroir and the farming. That’s where a lot of those ideas started.
Harmon Skurnik 7:22
Before we picked up this domaine, which is now several years ago, I had an impression of this domaine as just another typical Alsatian domaine of a very high quality, great reputation. But visiting there and learning about how they do things, it really blew my mind. I think they’re revelatory. So with that in mind, I think we’ll go to the conversation that you had recently with Mathieu and listen in to somebody who I think is incredibly smart, incredibly intelligent, and he may win you over.
David Hinkle 7:52
One of the most thoughtful, provocative people. I love listening to Mathieu. I want to jump in and listen again.
Harmon Skurnik 7:59
Let’s do it.
Communicating terroir through field blending
David Hinkle 8:01
Thank you for coming to New York. It’s great to see you here.
Mathieu Deiss 8:05
Yeah, thank you, David, for the invitation.
David Hinkle 8:07
This is exciting because it’s one of my truly favorite families, one of my favorite places. I love Alsace. It’s not maybe the first place that people think of when they go to France, to go to wine regions, but it may be the most beautiful, and I think has some of the most exciting wines of today, and truly the leader in the area is your family. We had an amazing seminar today, and I wanted to focus on a couple subjects. I was thinking one that you and your family are so passionate about is complantation, co-planting in the vineyards, and I’d love if you could give us a little bit of the history of that and why it is so crucial to the, I would say even, the future of wine growing in Alsace and maybe in some other regions of the world too with climate change.
Mathieu Deiss 8:58
Yeah, for us, this question of the complantation was coming on the way of the expression of the terroir. The beginning point is just very basic, that my father spent a lot of time trying to explain the Grand Cru Altenberg de Bergheim. At the beginning, we had the Grand Cru Altenberg Riesling, Pinot Gris, Gewürztraminer. People were coming, having a very nice tasting, beautiful experience, but they were coming back later, five, ten years later, and they wanted to taste, for example, the Pinot Gris Grand Cru. They come back and say, “Hey, Jean-Michel, we had a great moment. Let us taste with some friends your Pinot Gris Grand Cru.” For a lot of people, that’s not a problem when you ask like this, but for my father, who lives wine through the terroir, it was a little bit like if you go to Burgundy and you go to some of the top wineries and you say, “Okay, let me taste your Pinot Noir Grand Cru.” It’s like you don’t understand what terroir is. And my father didn’t know how to break that, how to push the terroir in front of the varietal, because it’s no problem with the Riesling, the Pinot Gris, and all this. They’re beautiful grapes. It’s just that the terroir is starting to speak when it’s above the varietal. We had the chance at this time to get a new Grand Cru, the Schoenenbourg, and half was Riesling, and the other half was a very, very old parcel, already more than 80 years old. It was a field blend, and my father vinified both separately. And when he does a blind tasting with people, everybody is always able to find Altenberg versus Schoenenbourg and the two cuvées of the Schoenenbourg, but nobody is able to say which one of the Schoenenbourg was the Riesling and which one was the field blend.
David Hinkle 10:49
Will you explain field blend too, maybe just to clarify it?
Mathieu Deiss 10:53
Yeah, yeah, completely. To clarify it, a field blend is basically the old tradition in Europe where people used to plant all the varieties completely together. And when I say completely together, it’s really like no rules, no organization, no rows, no different timing of picking, none of that. One parcel, a diversity inside, picked in one moment, and the unity is the terroir. That’s the key. So we did that, so that was the beginning of the story. Then my father decided to say, “Okay, if we would like to make the idea of Schoenenbourg, Altenberg, Mambourg, and the others, we need to force people to think of the wine like a person, like an entity.” Removing the grape and having the diversity like it was before was the way to force them to remember about Schoenenbourg and Altenberg. Where it’s starting to get interesting is that it’s coming from a question of taste and this energy, this idea to push the terroir first. But then along the way, we started to realize what the story was behind that. Complantation, you have to understand, is kind of the father of the appellation system. “Appellation,” in French, is coming from the word “appeler,” which means “to name something.” It means that at this period of time, people were not able to name the wine in another way than expressing the valley, the village, the hill, the river, whatever—using the name of the origin of the place because, anyway, from a varietal point of view, there was no objective way to describe it. So that’s really the beginning.
Gaining stability from diversity
Mathieu Deiss 12:52
This question of field blending has a real farmer origin, because one of the biggest problems, if you look at 200 years ago, was for people to have stable production. They were farmers. The distinction of a farmer is that when he is producing too much, it’s like milk. If you make too much milk, people dump it onto the ground because there is no price for the milk. If you don’t have anything, you cannot pay the work to do it, so it’s the opposite. So what a farmer historically tried to do is have the most consistency. And so actually, consistency, the best way to have it, was to have this diversity, this biodiversity, which was making an average, a balance between the production. Maybe one year, one grape variety was producing too much, and maybe another, nothing. Some are more sensitive to the heat, some others to the dryness, some others to the bad weather, so actually, having a diversity was, for a farmer, a very basic way to find stability. People were not able to explain that like we do today. They just saw with their own eyes that it was working better.
Harmon Skurnik 14:11
It was instinct.
Mathieu Deiss 14:12
Instinctive. And what is quite funny, or actually not so funny with the reality of everyday work from a farming point of view, is that climate change was, for a long time, a help to have better maturity. But over the last 15 years, we’re starting to get to a moment where climate change is starting to be a new challenge with some production issues, some quality issues. And if you listen to society, globally you hear more and more words like “diversity,” “biodiversity,” “resilience”—in French, “robustesse.” This is very trendy, in a way. But you find that the stronger tool we have to answer this very modern situation is to actually look at the answer that people had put in place before. A lot of people speak about adaptation to the grapes, changing to varieties from the south, bringing them back to the north, or some hybrids, resistant to some disease and all that. At the end, even the people who were doing research about that all said that the easiest way would be to have a part of that on a diversity to slightly adapt. And I think that, in a way, today’s appellation system is quite dangerous because of the incapacity to change. The laws for the appellations are changing slower than the climate, and that’s a very big issue. At the same time, it’s maybe one of the best tools for the future because it will be very difficult for people to reinvent every 10 years or 15 years the comprehension of each area, the type of grapes, etc. What we need is a place of stability, so I think that’s a very nice, challenging way for the future to focus on this place.
David Hinkle 16:15
I think about it in terms of old gardens where the vegetables were. It wasn’t like, “Here we’re going to do the broccoli, here we’re going to do the carrots.” It was much more mixed, and I feel like putting trees back into the vineyards, which your father and family have been doing for years, I think all of these things together, the different grapes mixed in the vineyard, there is this balance that takes place. Some grapes get riper a little bit earlier. And I think one of the most interesting things you’ve talked about over the last few years is how for these grapes, the goal is not that they all ripen at the same time. It is, in fact, that they get in a range so they’re close.
Mathieu Deiss 17:00
Yeah, because first, a lot of people see that from an office or an armchair, but the question of maturity for a variety does not happen all at one point. When you work on the parcel, you see some grapes are a bit less mature, some grapes are a bit more, some grapes are a bit overripe. There is already a range. The question is how to put the different ranges of the different varieties close enough to pick everything together. And the change of weather, especially the temperature during the month of August—it’s because of this that the maturities are closer and closer. Today, a lot of people are bringing back some biodiversity. They put in trees, they put in flowers, they see different things and all that. But at the end, it’s a monoculture of wine with the same grapes, the same varieties, sometimes the same clones, and they put a bit of diversity around a little bit.
David Hinkle 17:59
Window dressing.
Mathieu Deiss 18:00
Et voilà. What’s funny is that this is going in the right direction, but it’s the complantation that is really starting this question from the center, that means the question of the culture, and breaking this idea of monoculture with only one variety, one point. And yeah, I think this idea is really strong because it’s very simple, actually, at the end.
David Hinkle 18:24
So, what you’re saying is, all of those things are good, very good for the diversity, but at the core of it, you still need the diversity of the varietals to make the whole really successful.
Mathieu Deiss 18:40
I just think that actually if you look at the culture and what is around, the two will cross one moment. This question of biodiversity, of resilience—do people trust it or not? I would say the climate will choose. It’s not a dogmatic point of view, it’s not to push one idea on top of another, it’s just a pragmatic, practical view.
The weakness of the appellation system
David Hinkle 19:08
Well, you made a great point today, too, that I love, that the appellation system has made mistakes and has been at times a part of the problem, but even reluctantly, the appellation rules are changing. It’s accepting that the monovarietal is probably not the solution, and that maybe there needs to be a greater solution. It may not be the right solution.
Mathieu Deiss 19:36
I’m not sure that for the moment it’s accepted in this way. I think for the moment the temptation is still to try to hide this, to fix a problem. The temptation for the moment is to try to make a hybrid resistant that we can call Riesling-something or directly Riesling, and will have a little bit the character, the aromatic character. It’s also in this direction, and the appellation system is the same. They’re starting to open the window. “Okay, we can keep the name of the variety if we have less than 15% of other grapes inside.” We’re open to experimentation etc., but at the end, all of that goes the same way. Reducing the monoculture opens the diversity.
David Hinkle 20:22
I’m being optimistic that maybe this is a movement towards something bigger, but maybe not.
Mathieu Deiss 20:29
One point was very difficult, and I go back to our situation in Alsace, is that the Alsatian appellation is very uncommon for a lot of people. The Alsatian appellation came after the Second World War, and we have something that the other regions in France don’t have. We had phylloxera from 1884 to 1886. It came slightly after the change of country when we turned into Germany in 1871. That means we lost more or less all the market, and we had to reinvent the market at the same time that we lost all the vineyards. The consequence was that Alsace lost almost 80 years of making wines because we went from 32,000 hectares to 3,000 hectares, and we kept these 3,000 hectares of vineyards for 80 years. It’s only after the Second World War that we started to replant, and that’s why the Alsace appellation is a little bit on the New World model. It’s quite weird to think that we have the New World in the middle of Europe; Strasbourg is a capital of Europe. At the end, people tried to find a solution to take this post-war productive agriculture to the old system of European appellation, and that’s why we had, at the same time, the terroir and the variety and all of that is not clear at all. I’m pretty sure that actually the explanation will come from the place at the end.
David Hinkle 22:07
Well, I think it’s happening. I do think it’s happening.
Why maceration makes a better fermentation
David Hinkle 22:10
I know that one thing that you and your wife have worked a lot at in the last five-plus years is maceration on a lot of your wines.
Mathieu Deiss 22:21
Just basically because when you macerate it, it’s fermenting better. One of the issues with global warming, or at least the heating and the dryness of the end of the season, is that juice is naturally fermenting less and less. You have to understand something very basic: the natural place for yeast is not a tank of juice. The tank of juice is coming with the human being. It’s really coming later in the history from a yeast’s point of view. The yeast’s point of view is, the fruit is falling to the floor, starting to break down, and the yeast can grow inside of this. All the nutrients, all that the yeast needs to grow is in the juice, but also on the skins, so it’s always fermenting better with the skins than without. That was our experience in trying to find a way to stay natural, without adding yeast, without correcting the juice, without adding nutrients, and blah blah blah. By just putting the yeast in a better situation, it works better. We used to take 5 to 10% of maceration that we blend with the direct press, just at least for putting in some healthy yeast that’s able to resist the alcohol and ferment that very well. Then we had a bit more volume than just the 5% we needed, so we also, for the fun of it, started to make some 100% maceration wine almost 12 years ago, quite earlier than the trendy orange blah blah. But it makes a lot of sense. And what I learned also on the way is that historically in Alsace, people used to destem part of the grapes and put that on the bottom of the tank before pouring the juice on top. We used to have a little part of maceration, not so much, but actually a little bit of tannic structure is also a very elegant way to give more body and texture to the wine. We protect the wine against oxidation without having to just be very technical with the sulfur. It’s a very gentle, elegant way to do it.
David Hinkle 24:37
For me, it’s an aspect of texture, that little bit of bitters, and as you say, it gives a structure to the wines that helps make it stronger, but also gives it some freshness and vibrancy.
Mathieu Deiss 24:50
That is completely an aesthetic point of view. The beginning point of all of that was just how to ferment better. The point about the bitterness, and maybe this is less well understood, is that the bitterness you have from the maceration, like from a red, when it doesn’t have air slowly and you don’t have this micro-oxygenation, you stay on a very green side of bitterness. But aging in the cellar helps the wine to be very elegant, polished, and not aggressive. That’s the point, that historically we give more value to wines that have aged than wines that aren’t aged. Also, I’m pretty sure that this kind of structure was more common 80 years ago or one century ago, because people didn’t have herbicides and the yields were lower, so at the end, less juice, more skins, and slower extraction because it was a manual press that we do very slowly, and also more competition for the vines because they were not able to remove all the grass and all. It was giving some structure to make it more able to age. And I’m not surprised that some appellations have, even on the low end, rules to keep the wine two, three, five years in the cellar. That makes a lot of sense. There is a part of all of that that we need, maybe not to reinvent, but just to re-understand and offer wine to the public when the wines are really ready.
David Hinkle 26:24
You can lay them away in the cellar even beforehand.
Mathieu Deiss 26:29
Yeah, because you cannot ask people to do part of the job instead of the producer.
The advantages of a long press
David Hinkle 26:34
One last question, because I know you like to do a very long press. Can you talk about the advantage of doing that? Because it’s quite long compared to some other regions.
Mathieu Deiss 26:45
We do this because it’s a way to have clear juice, reducing the bad side of the bitterness, the very green side, without having to filter the juice and without having to cool the juice after pressing. Because the time you take to filter it and the time you take to make the juice very cold means that you will have to add yeast after to ferment because otherwise it doesn’t go well. You’re taking a lot of risk, taking time to warm up to the temperature that yeast can ferment, so people have to add the yeast to do it. If you would like to have a very direct—I was on the way to say translation, but it’s a fermentation, but—translation from the place to the wine to the bottle, to have something very transparent, is just to touch the juice as little as possible. No filtration, no reducing the temperature, no selected yeast, but not by dogma, just by the ambition to not change the taste from the origin. Long pressing is part of this.
David Hinkle 27:55
It’s a very slow, long press. About how long, on average?
Mathieu Deiss 27:59
12 hours minimum, and we go up to 20 if we have time. It depends on the moment of the harvest, because we have a very long harvest and we have more time at the beginning than at the end.
David Hinkle 28:11
So that gives you a gentler extraction from the skins.
Mathieu Deiss 28:15
Yeah.
David Hinkle 28:16
I wish we could talk for a lot longer, but we’ve got to catch a plane. Thank you so much, Mathieu. It’s a real treat to have you here in New York.
Mathieu Deiss 28:25
Thank you, David.
Skurnik Unfiltered is recorded at Skurnik Wines & Spirits headquarters in the Flatiron District of New York City. If you found the conversation interesting, please consider liking, subscribing, and leaving a review. You can stay up to date on our show and upcoming events by following @skurnikwines on Instagram and visiting our website at skurnik.com